ModCloth Dresses Review

About ModCloth

ModCloth is an online retailer of clothing, shoes, and accessories that caters to women of all sizes. It carries retro, hard-to-find pieces picked from small and big-name designers, as well as its own signature collection. 

The brand has an outstanding 713K following on Instagram, and encourages women to express themselves by way of bold prints and flattering styles. 

Love the spirit of vintage clothing? Your search for the perfect piece may have just ended. Before you start shopping, we invite you to have a read through this ModCloth dresses review. 

We’ll cover some bestsellers, customer feedback, FAQs, and more, to help you decide if they’re the right fit for your style. 

Overview of ModCloth

Founded in 2002 by Susan Gregg Koger and Eric Koger, ModCloth has been through a rollercoaster of ownerships while searching for its place in the market. Recently, the brand has landed with Nogin, an expert in the online world of fashion. 

ModCloth began as a place where women could find out-of-the-ordinary styles, thrilling prints, and vintage designs that had a special feel about them. 

The brand—housing its own collection alongside labels like Chi Chi London and Princess Highway—sells retro-inspired picks, along with some versatile basics to compliment funky skirts and overalls. 

ModCloth’s signature apparel is designed and hand-stitched in Portland, Oregon, but its headquarters are based in LA. 

Now that you know a little more about the brand’s roots, this ModCloth dresses review will go over some pros and cons. 

Pros

• Variety of attire ranging from clothing to shoes and accessories
• Offers a unique collection alongside a curated list of vintage-inspired designers
• ModCloth’s collection is made locally 
• A spectrum of price points 
• ModCloth outlet offers great deals
• Positive customer reviews on quality 

Cons

• Only ships within the US at this time
• Short returns window 

ModCloth is known for its eye-catching designs. Within its collection of dresses, casual attire, shoes, and accessories, you’ll feel as if you’re hunting through a bin of vintage treasures. 

Redesigned with modern fabrics and flattering fits, the brand’s apparel features cutesy prints, bold colors, and adorable themes. 

This is a ModCloth dresses review, so we’ll be sticking to the brand’s dresses mostly, but you’ll also find a few unique swimsuits and cute footwear thrown in as well—because a girl’s gotta cool down, and she definitely needs a heel to go with those outfits!

ModCloth Dresses Review

There’s something special about dresses. Maybe it’s their twirl-ability or perhaps that the most gorgeous ones are saved for special occasions. Whether it’s for birthday parties, restaurant dates, or weddings, shopping for a dress is an exciting task. 

Casual or fancy, the brand’s collection of flowy dresses is spirited, sweet, and classy (with a hint of drama every now and again). This ModCloth dresses review will feature a few of their bestsellers below. 

ModCloth Gilded Grace Lace Dress Review

The Gilded Grace Lace Dress looks like it stepped off the scene of a fairytale movie. A modern take on a whimsical princess dress, this enchanting gown exudes romance. 

A shoulder-skimming neckline is accented by sheet intricate lace detailing, while that same lace rims the bottom hem. Swirls decorated with glints of gold make their way up the tulle skirt. 

The dress is made from 100% polyamide, fully lined with polyester and elastane fabric for comfort, and features a side zipper closure. 

Feel the love in the Gilded Grace Lace Dress for $180. It comes in blush and champagne colors. 

ModCloth Wandering Amongst the Lily Leaves Midi Dress Review 

Created with fabric in the shade of a gentle morning mist shade, this nature-inspired midi dress is a breath of fresh air. Leaves, delicate beading, and sequins creep across the bodice and down the sheer sleeves, while the high neckline puckers at the top for a modest but eye-catching detail. 

The Wandering Amongst the Lily Leaves Midi Dress has a sleek, swishy skirt, ideal for twirling around with the one you love. It would be perfect for the winter season, perhaps at an indoor wedding that takes place in a flower-decorated greenhouse. 

Fully lined and made from polyester, this A-line dress is $160. 

ModCloth Wedding Dresses Review

Wedding dresses are particularly important and shopping for them requires a little extra attention. Just like other gowns though, there are a plethora of choices—short, long, princess, modest…The list goes on, and we like it that way. 

Regardless of the dress, you want your personality to shine through. The vintage-inspired brand carries a varied collection of wedding dresses, and we’ll be covering two of their biggest hits next in this ModCloth dresses review. 

ModCloth Something Borrowed Something Blithe Dress Review 

With its modern, graceful style, this sleek ModCloth wedding dress skims over your hips and falls just underfoot. Sheer, short sleeves are accented with sweet dots, and the lace overlay across the skirt brings texture and exciting detail to the otherwise smooth gown. 

A fine choice for a garden-set wedding, naturalistas may want to go barefoot or don a flower crown made of tiny buds and blossoms. The Something Borrowed Something Blithe Dress is fully lined with a back zipper and hook, with eye closure. 

Available in white only, this darling wedding gown is $170 (on sale from $200). 

ModCloth With Lasting Joy Maxi Dress Review 

The With Lasting Joy Maxi Dress is what we have in mind when picturing a 1950s wedding. Modest with just a peek at the shoulders, this flowing polyester and elastase gown starts with a spaghetti strap top, glides over hips, and brushes the ground with a fishtail hem. 

A classic pick, the top is covered by a sheer, lace overlay with a scalloped edge to add texture and variation. The polyamide overlay is completely removable if at any time you feel like baring your shoulders. 

Traditional with a twist, this classy ModCloth wedding gown is $360. 

ModCloth Plus Size Review

Plus size clothes don’t need to look different than regular size versions, but yet, so many brands opt for matronly prints or unflattering cuts. Our featured brand doesn’t. 

You’ll find the same thrilling prints and complimentary designs throughout their collections, such as their two bestsellers featured below in this ModCloth dresses review. 

ModCloth x Collectif Beauty and The Beachcomber Midi Dress Review 

Totally tropical, this colorful, viscose dress was born from a collaboration with Collectif, a vintage and rockabilly brand. A traditional square neckline keeps things retro, while navy and white palm trees dance across a pink sky. 

This A-Line dress has a sash-tie waist to accent your natural shape, while adjustable tie shoulders add a cute, casual detail. This playful dress is perfect for hot days and relaxing afternoons. And the best part—you’ll find pockets on each side. 

Because fit and quality are important, the Beauty and The Beachcomber Midi Dress has a zipper and hook and eye closure. Available in sizes 4–30, you can feel the breeze in this shift dress for $90. 

ModCloth Frill Seeker Pleated Mini Skirt Review 

This skirt is so 70s. With pleats, pastels, and popping yellow, the Frill Seeker Pleated Mini Skirt shouts fun from the rooftops. Remembering to keep things classy, it’s lined with polyester and spandex for comfort, with just a hint of thigh shown at the base through the sheer overlay. 

Tuck a simple tee in this high-waisted piece, and finish the look off with a jean jacket and low-top sneakers. Artsy details like splats of muted colors and an off-center button closure pump up the volume and make this polyester skirt one to be admired. 

Available in sizes 0–16, the Frill Seeker Pleated Mini Skirt costs $70. 

ModCloth Swimsuits Review

The ModCloth swimsuits collection is full of vintage-inspired cuts with popping prints and colors. High-waisted bottoms and full-coverage tops fill the brand’s lineup, along with classy one-pieces that provide coverage but don’t skimp on pretty detailing. 

This ModCloth dresses review will feature two of the brand’s most popular picks below, to give you an idea of what we mean. 

ModCloth The Brooke One-Piece Swimsuit Review 

Sweet daisies decorate the cool, minty backdrop of The Brooke One-Piece Swimsuit. With a halter top tie and plunging V neckline, though this suit is more on the modest side, it makes sure to accentuate your curves. 

The tie waist makes sure too, cinching you in at your smallest point. With a bikini cut, you’ll get full coverage on front and back, though the edgy criss-cross detailing on the back pumps up the fun. 

It’s made from a mix of polyester and elastase, as most swimsuits are, but provides SPF 50 protection. Get it in sizes XS–4X for $100. 

ModCloth The Lula One Piece Review 

Bring out your inner kid with this quirky aquatic swimsuit. The Lula One Piece features a mix of calming blue and white dots with a few happy dolphins swimming across the surface. 

A deep neckline down to your belly button brings some sex appeal to the one-piece, which has a strap underneath your chest for a little extra support. Thick shoulders straps keep things retro, while the open back lets you show off while doing those laps. 

Made from polyester and elastane, The Lula One Piece swimsuit is yours for $90. 

ModCloth Shoes Review

Shoes add the finishing touch to any outfit. The wrong pair can totally create the wrong look. If you’re browsing ModCloth’s collection for clothes, then you can keep things retro with your choice of kicks as well. 

This ModCloth dresses review will fill you in on the brand’s most popular heels below. One of these might pair perfectly with the outfit you have in mind. 

ModCloth Such a Babe Platform Heel Review 

Strut your stuff in the Such a Babe Platform Heel. The block heel and platform base give these ModCloth shoes a totally vintage look that pairs well with a variety of looks. 

Available in a tender pink shade, wear these leather heels with a long jean skirt and a casual tee. Or, go bold with a tiny jumpsuit, sun hat, and oversized, round sunnies. 

Do the hustle in the Such a Babe Platform Heel for $82. 

ModCloth Traverse and Chorus Heel Review 

Classy and full of character, the Traverse and Chorus Heel looks like it was kicked off the foot of Elizabeth Taylor. It’s a low, thicker heel, with just enough height to give your calves a sexy boost. 

The tiny peep toe adds a sweet detail, while the crossing straps and subtle stitching add elegance. Step into the past with the Traverse and Chorus Heel for $72. 

Is ModCloth Ethical? 

ModCloth doesn’t give enough information on its website to tell if it is an ethical line or not. In the Good On You directory, the brand gets a 2/5 smiley face rating, meaning they need to do better.

Who Is ModCloth For? 

If you find yourself digging through the racks at thrift stores in your spare time, then you probably would find ModCloth’s pieces enchanting. With a throw-back style to ‘50’s, ‘60s, and ‘70’s fashion, the brand uses fun and interesting prints to offer out-of-the-box clothing.  

The company’s collection is full of modest cuts; some display sexy detailing without going overboard. Offering a ModCloth plus size collection, women up to size 30 can find something within the various categories.  

The fun prints mean the brand would be enjoyed by Gen Z, but the quality and fit are what captures the attention of Gen X. 

Comparison: ModCloth vs. A’Gaci  

Clothing from the past is very attractive. The designs, the details, the patterns…It’s no wonder fast-fashion brands are taking inspiration from it today. And why there are brands who offer similar lineups. 

In this section of our ModCloth dresses review, we’ll be doing a quick comparison between our featured brand and A’Gaci, a modern clothing retailer that’s all about empowering women through clothing. Let’s see how the two stack up against one another. 

Though A’Gaci certainly has some styles that reflect vintage designs—like off-the-shoulder tops, and playful jumpsuits—overall, it’s not a vintage-inspired brand. In terms of what it offers, its categories are similar to ModCloth, being that they carry clothing, dresses, plus size, accessories, and swimwear items. 

Though A’Gaci doesn’t carry shoes, ModCloth doesn’t carry lingerie, so we can consider them equal at this point. How about price and quality? 

When searching through A’Gaci’s breezy collection of shirts and flowing sundresses, it was tough to find an item that matched in terms of looks. They all have a more modern cut, whereas our featured brand is totally retro. 

We went with The ModCloth Tiered Sleeveless Shift Dress ($90) and the A’Gaci Gingham Tiered Dress ($73), which though the cuts are different, the idea is the same. 

In terms of quality, we’d say they’re on par. Both made of 100% cotton, they are equally as lightweight, though our competitors may be a bit thicker. Is thicker a sign of greater quality? Not always. 

The main difference between these companies is the design of the clothing. The prices aren’t too far off, but ModCloths, in general, tend to be higher. It also has fancier selections, and a less fast-fashion feel to it. 

ModCloth Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

We get it. Online shopping, though exciting, is tough. And sometimes you add 27 items to your basket and never checkout simply because you’re unsure of the quality of the clothing and the reliability of the brand. 

That’s why this ModCloth dresses review exists. We’ve done the search for real customer feedback for you so you can enjoy your online shopping experience for what it should be: easy and fun!

Modcloth showcases customer comments, but it hasn’t received a ton of ratings for its clothing. We’ve rounded up a few for you below, but just keep in mind that without a substantial amount of reviews, these ratings may not give an accurate depiction of the brand. 

• Something Borrowed Something Blithe Dress: 5/5 stars from 2 reviews
• Gilded Grace Lace Dress: 4.3/5 stars from 300 reviews
• A Spring Garden Fling Fit and Flare Dress: 3.5/5 stars from 2 reviews
• You’ve Been Ghosted Fair Isle Sweater: 5/5 stars from 2 reviews
• A MidSummer’s Daydream Embroidered Maxi Dress: 3/5 stars from 3 reviews

The Gilded Grace Lace Dress stands out from the bunch as the brand’s most popular dress. Let’s find out why. One buyer writes, “Not uncomfortable. Never worried something was draping wrong. It’s just beautiful and perfect.” 

Lots of shoppers actually bought this as their wedding dress, so considering they felt gorgeous and comfortable all day and night while wearing it says a lot.

There are quite a few 3/5 star reviews for this piece, with most of them concerning the overall appeal of the dress. One important comment about the color reads, “The champagne color is a lot more yellow than in the picture.” Color differences are always a little disappointing, but in terms of fit, dresses will look different on unique bodies, so it’s important to keep that in mind when shopping. 

To see if we could find a source with more reviews, we headed over to Influenster to see how its members ranked the brand. The site showed a 4.3/5 star rating among 1,027 reviews. We’ve included the rating snapshot below in case you’d like to see how those numbers were calculated:

• 5 stars 54%
• 4 stars 33%
• 3 stars 11%
• 2 stars 1%
• 1 star 2%

So, about 97% of customers had an average to excellent experience with ModCloth, and a very small number said that it was poor or bad. We tried to find some common themes. Shoppers speak of well-made pieces, along with “fantastic customer service,” and fast shipping. 

One ModCloth dresses review mentioned the brand’s selection of plus size clothing. It reads, “As a plus sized shopper I cannot stress enough how hard it is to buy clothes that fit properly and are stylish. To me this company should win many awards just for the fact that they have this.” Inclusive, attractive clothing is a must, and something that we’re glad this brand carries. 

So what did those 3% not like about it? Well, one angry customer seems to sum all complaints up in one unhappy comment, “The quality has gone way down. Takes forever for returns. Sizing is inconsistent. Tired of seeing the same hideous clothes in newer uglier prints,” and it goes on. Yikes. It’s always sad to see reviews like this, but style is a preference. 

To see if the brand truly holds up in the customer service department, we switched over to the Better Business Bureau. Finding an A+ rating and just 15 issues noted in the last 3 years, we learned that ModCloth resolved all of those complaints and only received 3 in the last 12 months. 

From our research, it appears that ModCloth is a solid brand with a reliable customer service team and quality clothing. At times, customers vent about the pricing as well as how certain items fit, but there were very few disappointed with the quality. 

Is ModCloth Worth It?

High quality and style need to back up a steep price tag. From what we’ve seen and read about ModCloth, their clothing appears to check off both boxes. 

ModCloth carries other designers as well as its signature line, such as Betsy Johnson and even Hello Kitty. So as you can imagine, the price range varies depending on the label. 

The idea behind the brand is meaningful and its clothing resembles the well-made hand-sewn items of the era it takes inspiration from. ModCloth suits a particular style, yes, so not everyone who enters its site is going to fall in love with the collections. 

If you like bold prints, fun designs, and classic styles, ModCloth may be exactly what you’ve been looking for. Based on our findings, we believe that the company is worth checking out. 

ModCloth Promotions & Discounts 

We know all too well how quickly that cart total adds up! To help lessen the blow, the company offers a few discounts. You’ll find them compiled into a neat little list directly below in this ModCloth dresses review.

• Get a 15% off ModCloth coupon when you sign up for the brand’s newsletter
• BOGO Dress Sale: To buy one and get one 50% off, use the ModCloth promo code DRESS50 at checkout
• Free shipping on orders over $125

Where to Buy ModCloth

You can shop the brand’s vintage-inspired collection exclusively on ModCloth.com. 

FAQ

Who is ModCloth owned by? 

ModCloth was originally founded by Susan Gregg Koger and Eric Koger. It has since been passed around among several parent companies, including Walmart, Go Global Retail, and now Nogin. 

Where is ModCloth made? 

ModCloth carries different designer labels that manufacture items around the world. The brand’s signature line is stitched in Portland, Oregon. 

Does ModCloth fit true to size? 

Fit is a personal thing. There have been a few customer reviews that mention ModCloth’s clothing runs large, but generally, their items fit true to size. 

ModCloth carries quite a few different labels, all with their unique measurements. Typically, they stock the following sizes in dresses, tops, bottoms, and shoes (some items have limited sizes):

• Dresses: XXS–4X
• Tops: XXS–4X
• Bottoms: 00–30
• Shoes: 36–42

If you need more information about ModCloth sizing, have a look at the chart below. 

What is ModCloth’s Shipping Policy?

ModCloth normally ships to the US and international locations, but until further notice, they have canceled international shipments. You can find all domestic delivery options listed below:

Contiguous US:

• Ground shipping: 2–5 business days, $8, or free on orders over $125
• Expedited shipping: 2–3 business days, $14
• Next-day shipping: 1 business day, $21

Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico:

• SmartPost standard shipping: 10–12 business days, $19

APO/FPO

• USPS: 10–15 business days 

ModCloth estimates processing times to typically fall between 1–3 business days. Once your order ships, you’ll receive a confirmation email with a tracking link. 

What is ModCloth’s Return Policy?

Some things to keep in mind when returning ModCloth items:

1. The brand must receive your return within 30 days from the date of purchase
2. All items need to be in brand new condition with tags attached
3. You cannot return final sale items
4. Domestic US returns are free, a shipping label will be provided
5. Return processing can take up to 14 days

To start a return, head to the ModCloth’s returns portal.

How to Contact ModCloth

Have any questions beyond this ModCloth dresses review? You can use any of the methods below to get in touch with the brand:

• Phone: (888)495-9699
• Email: [email protected]
• Live chat on their website

---

Looking for more beautiful dresses? Check out Adrianna Papell or Gorman, two brands that we highly recommend.