Simple Modern Harper Tote vs MZ Wallace Totes:  Which One Offers the Best Value?

About Simple Modern Harper Tote

Simple Modern, founded in 2015 and based in Oklahoma, USA, is a brand on a mission to make stylish and functional products accessible to everyone. They believe that quality and affordability shouldn’t be mutually exclusive, and this philosophy is reflected in their diverse range of drinkware, bags and accessories. 

While they’re best known for their colorful and customizable tumblers, their Harper Tote showcases their commitment to creating well-designed everyday essentials that elevate your lifestyle.  

About MZ Wallace Totes

MZ Wallace, established in 2000 in the heart of New York City’s Soho district, embodies a sophisticated and urban aesthetic.  Founded by Monica Zwirner and Lucy Wallace Eustice, the brand was born from a desire to create bags that could seamlessly transition between the various demands of a modern woman’s life.  

MZ Wallace totes are known for their lightweight yet durable construction, often featuring quilted nylon and leather accents. 

What to Consider?

Both brands offer stylish and functional totes designed for the modern individual, but they cater to different needs and preferences.  In this comparison, we’ll delve into the key distinctions between these brands, exploring their design philosophies, features, price points, and overall value proposition.  By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which tote is the perfect fit for your lifestyle and budget.

Price

When investing in a tote bag that you’ll use day in and day out, it’s important to consider both price and value.  What are you getting for your money? How does the price tag align with the quality, features, and overall longevity of the bag?  Let’s explore how Simple Modern and MZ Wallace compare in this crucial category.

Simple Modern Harper Tote

Priced at $124.99, the Harper Tote offers exceptional value for its quality and features. It’s a well-made, stylish tote that doesn’t break the bank, making it an accessible option for a wider range of consumers. You get a lot for your money with this tote: durable quilted nylon construction, multiple pockets and compartments for organization, a padded laptop sleeve, comfortable carrying options, and a sleek design that can easily transition from day to night.

MZ Wallace Totes

MZ Wallace totes, on the other hand, are significantly more expensive, with prices often ranging from $200 to $400 or more. While their bags are undoubtedly stylish and well-made, the higher price tag might be a barrier for some shoppers. 

Verdict

If you’re looking for a high-quality tote that doesn’t compromise on style or functionality but also doesn’t break the bank, the Simple Modern Harper Tote is the clear winner in this category. It offers exceptional value for its price, making it a more accessible and budget-friendly option compared to MZ Wallace totes.

Design and Aesthetics

When it comes to aesthetics, Simple Modern and MZ Wallace each have a distinct personality. One embraces a playful and expressive vibe, while the other exudes a more classic and understated elegance. Let’s explore how their design philosophies translate into their tote bags.

Simple Modern Harper Tote

The Harper Tote is all about modern simplicity with a touch of fun. Its quilted nylon construction adds a touch of texture and sophistication, while the minimalist hardware and clean lines create a streamlined silhouette. Available in a variety of colors, from classic neutrals to vibrant hues, the Harper Tote allows you to express your personal style while maintaining a timeless appeal.

MZ Wallace Totes

MZ Wallace totes, on the other hand, embody a more classic and understated elegance. Their signature quilted nylon fabric, often paired with leather accents, creates a luxurious and refined look. The designs are typically minimalist, with a focus on clean lines and functional silhouettes. While they offer a range of colors, their palette tends to lean towards neutral and sophisticated tones.

Verdict

Both Simple Modern and MZ Wallace offer stylish totes, but their aesthetics cater to different tastes. If you prefer a modern, versatile look with a touch of personality, the Simple Modern Harper Tote might be more your style. 

Functionality

Beyond just looking good, a tote bag needs to perform its primary function: carrying your belongings efficiently and conveniently. Let’s examine how Simple Modern and MZ Wallace approach functionality and features in their tote designs.

Simple Modern Harper Tote

The Harper Tote is designed with organization and accessibility in mind. It features a variety of pockets and compartments to keep your essentials in order, including:

• Exterior pockets. Two large exterior pockets for quick access to frequently used items.
• Interior pockets. Three small interior pockets for organizing smaller items and a zippered pocket for valuables.
• Water bottle pockets. Four elastic water bottle pockets to keep drinks upright and prevent spills.
• Padded laptop sleeve. A dedicated sleeve with a magnetic closure to protect your laptop or tablet (up to 13 inches).

So, the Harper Tote also offers versatile carrying options with its comfortable handles and a detachable, adjustable crossbody strap. Plus, the built-in key leash ensures you’ll never lose your keys again!

MZ Wallace Totes

MZ Wallace totes are also known for their functionality, although the specific features can vary depending on the style. Many of their totes include features like:

• Zip-top closure. To keep your belongings secure.
• Interior pockets. For organization.
• Lightweight construction. For easy carrying.

However, MZ Wallace totes generally don’t have dedicated water bottle pockets or laptop sleeves, which might be a drawback for some users.

Verdict

The Simple Modern Harper Tote takes the lead in this category due to its thoughtful organization and variety of features designed to enhance functionality. While MZ Wallace totes offer practicality, the Harper Tote’s dedicated compartments, versatile carrying options, and attention to detail make it a more convenient and adaptable choice for everyday use.

Durability of Materials

It’s important to consider the materials and construction of a tote bag to ensure it can withstand the demands of everyday use. Both Simple Modern and MZ Wallace prioritize durability, but they utilize different approaches. Let’s examine the specifics.

Simple Modern Harper Tote

The Harper Tote is crafted entirely from quilted nylon, a lightweight yet durable material known for its resistance to water and wear. This choice of material contributes to the tote’s overall resilience and ensures it can handle daily use without showing excessive signs of wear and tear.

MZ Wallace Totes

MZ Wallace totes often combine quilted nylon with Italian leather trim. While this combination offers a sophisticated aesthetic and reinforces high-wear areas, it can introduce potential inconsistencies in durability. Leather, while generally durable, can be more prone to scratches and scuffs compared to nylon.

Verdict

In this category, the Simple Modern Harper Tote might have a slight edge. Its consistent use of quilted nylon throughout its construction ensures uniform wear and tear, reducing the risk of one material degrading faster than another. This focus on a single, durable material contributes to the tote’s overall longevity and ability to maintain its appearance over time.

Sustainability and Ethics

Consumers today care about more than just a brand’s products; they want to support companies that align with their values. Both Simple Modern and MZ Wallace have made strides in sustainability and ethical practices, but they approach these commitments in distinct ways. Let’s examine how they measure up.

Simple Modern

Simple Modern takes a multi-faceted approach to sustainability, focusing on three key areas:

• Recycled Materials. They actively incorporate recycled materials into their products, reducing their environmental footprint and reliance on virgin resources.
• Ethical Manufacturing. Simple Modern partners with factories that prioritize fair labor practices and safe working conditions for their employees.
• Charitable Giving. They donate a portion of their profits to support various charitable causes, including organizations focused on environmental conservation and social justice.

MZ Wallace

MZ Wallace also prioritizes sustainability, but their efforts are primarily concentrated on:

• Durable Products. They design their bags to be long-lasting, reducing the need for frequent replacements and minimizing waste.
• Responsible Sourcing. MZ Wallace emphasizes sourcing materials from suppliers who adhere to ethical and environmental standards.
• Recycled Packaging. They utilize recycled and recyclable materials in their packaging to minimize their environmental impact.

Verdict

Both Simple Modern and MZ Wallace are making commendable efforts towards sustainability. However, Simple Modern’s broader approach, which includes charitable giving alongside responsible manufacturing and material sourcing, might resonate more strongly with consumers who want their purchases to contribute to a greater good. 

Simple Modern Harper Tote vs MZ Wallace Tote: What Do Customers Think?

Simple Modern

Customers praise the Simple Modern Harper Tote for its thoughtful design and practicality. They appreciate the tote’s ability to keep them organized with its multiple compartments and pockets, making it easy to find essentials quickly. 

One reviewer shared, “I love my tote. Use it for work and I like the feeling of the fabric and the light weight even though I carry a lot of work items.” 

The Harper Tote’s versatility is also a highlight, with customers noting its suitability for various occasions, from work and travel to everyday errands. 

Another reviewer commented, “Lightweight, functional, sleek & modern.” 

Overall, Simple Modern customers value the Harper Tote for its ability to combine style and functionality in a way that enhances their everyday lives.

MZ Wallace

MZ Wallace totes also receive positive feedback for their stylish aesthetics and practical features. Customers appreciate the totes’ ability to seamlessly transition between different settings, from work to weekend, and their lightweight design makes them comfortable to carry throughout the day. 

One reviewer said, “Love the color and I take the bag with me everywhere.” The totes’ organizational features, including multiple pockets and compartments, are also a highlight for many users. 

One reviewer exclaimed, “So many pockets, it’s just fabulous…” 

So, the MZ Wallace customers value the totes for their combination of style, functionality, and lightweight design.

Simple Modern Harper Tote vs MZ Wallace Tote: Promotions and Discounts

Simple Modern

Simple Modern is quite generous with its discounts and promotions, making it easy to snag a deal on their drinkware and accessories, including the Harper Tote. Here’s how you can save:

• Free Shipping. Enjoy free shipping on orders over $25 within the contiguous United States. This is a fantastic perk, especially when purchasing larger items like the Harper Tote.  
• Welcome Discount. New customers can usually grab a discount on their first order simply by signing up for Simple Modern’s email list. This also keeps you informed about future sales and new product launches.
• Seasonal Sales. Simple Modern frequently runs seasonal sales and promotions throughout the year, offering opportunities to save on various items, including the Harper Tote. These sales often coincide with holidays or special events, so keep an eye out for those announcements.
• Rewards Program. Become a member of Simple Modern’s rewards program and earn points for every purchase. These points can be redeemed for discounts on future orders, making it a rewarding way to save on your favorite Simple Modern products.  
• Social Media Perks. Stay connected with Simple Modern on social media platforms like Instagram and Facebook. They often run exclusive contests, giveaways, and flash sales for their followers.  
• Bundle Up and Save. Look for bundled discounts when purchasing multiple items together. This can be a great way to save on a Harper Tote and a matching tumbler or other accessories.
• Collaborations and Partnerships. Simple Modern occasionally partners with other brands or influencers to offer exclusive discounts or limited-edition products. Keep an eye out for these collaborations for unique finds and potential savings.  

MZ Wallace

MZ Wallace, being a more premium brand, offers fewer discounts and promotions compared to Simple Modern. However, there are still ways to save:

• Seasonal Sales. MZ Wallace occasionally holds seasonal sales, particularly around holidays or end-of-season clearances. These sales might offer discounts on select items or across their entire collection.
• Email Sign-Up Offers. Similar to Simple Modern, MZ Wallace might offer a discount for new customers who sign up for their email list. This is a good way to stay informed about any upcoming sales or promotions.
• Retailer Promotions. Keep an eye on department stores or online retailers that carry MZ Wallace bags, as they might occasionally offer discounts or promotions on their selection.

Verdict

If you’re looking for consistent deals and promotions, Simple Modern is the clear winner. Their frequent sales, rewards program, and social media exclusives make it easier to save money on their products, including the Harper Tote. 

While MZ Wallace offers occasional discounts, their premium pricing and less frequent promotions might make it harder to find a bargain. However, it’s always a good idea to check both brands’ websites and social media for current offers before making a purchase.

Simple Modern Harper Tote vs MZ Wallace Tote: Shipping and Return

Simple Modern

Simple Modern offers free standard shipping on orders over $25 within the contiguous United States. Most orders ship out within 1-3 business days and arrive within 4-8 business days after shipping. If you need your order sooner, expedited shipping is available for a fee. They also offer international shipping to Canada for a flat rate of $25. Keep in mind that personalized orders require an additional 5 days of handling time.

For returns, Simple Modern has a 90-day return window for non-defective products. Items must be unused and in their original packaging to be eligible for a full refund. However, limited edition drops, personalized orders, and purchases shipped to Hawaii, Alaska, Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, and Canada are not eligible for return. Restocking fees may apply to large orders and frequent returns.

MZ Wallace

MZ Wallace offers free standard shipping for members of their MZW Rewards program in the continental US, Alaska, Hawaii, US Territories, and Puerto Rico. Non-members in the continental US will be charged a $10 ground shipping fee. Orders typically ship the next business day and arrive within 5-7 business days. For those who need their order sooner, expedited shipping options (2-day and overnight) are available for flat fees. MZ Wallace also offers free standard international shipping on orders that meet a minimum value (the minimum varies by country).

Their return policy allows for returns of unused items in their original packaging within 21 days of delivery. However, items purchased at a discount of 40% or more or from MZW Sample Sales are considered final sale and cannot be returned. All personalized orders are also final sale. For US returns using their FedEx return label, a $10 fee will be deducted from your refund, unless you are an MZW Rewards member. International returns incur a fee of $15-$20 USD.

Verdict

When comparing shipping and returns between Simple Modern and MZ Wallace, there are a few key differences to consider:

• Shipping Costs. Simple Modern offers free shipping on orders over $25, while MZ Wallace only offers free shipping to rewards members or on international orders over a certain amount. This makes Simple Modern more appealing for those looking to avoid shipping costs, especially on smaller orders.
  
• Return Window. Simple Modern has a more generous return window of 90 days compared to MZ Wallace’s 21 days. This gives customers more time to decide if they want to keep their purchase.

Who Will You Shop With?

Simple Modern’s Harper Tote emerges as the more appealing option for those seeking a combination of style, affordability, and thoughtful design. It’s a versatile everyday bag that doesn’t compromise on quality or functionality, while remaining accessible to a wider range of consumers. Its durable construction, organizational features, and comfortable carrying options make it a practical choice for everyday life, while its modern aesthetic and variety of colors ensure it complements your personal style.

MZ Wallace, while offering undeniably chic and high-quality totes, comes with a significantly higher price tag. This might be justified for those seeking a luxury bag with a more classic and understated aesthetic. However, for those who prioritize value and practicality without sacrificing style, the Simple Modern Harper Tote offers a compelling alternative.

---

Next, check out other articles that you might also like:

Simple Modern Harper Tote Review

10 Best Tote Bags For Women

Simple Modern Review