PetSafe’s GPS Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn GPS Dog Fences

Losing a beloved pet is a nightmare scenario for any dog owner. Whether your furry friend is an escape artist, a curious wanderer, or simply prone to chasing squirrels, the fear of them getting lost is always present. This common problem has led to the popularity of GPS dog fences, a technological solution that provides real-time tracking and peace of mind.

In this review, we will dive into GPS dog fences, focusing on three prominent options: PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn. Each system offers unique features and approaches, catering to different needs and preferences. By the end of this comparison, you’ll clearly understand what each brand offers, empowering you to decide and select the ideal GPS fence to safeguard your four-legged friend.

Whether you have a small yard, a sprawling estate, or simply want peace of mind while out on walks, we’ll guide you through the features, benefits, and considerations of each system. By understanding the strengths and potential limitations of each brand, you can confidently choose the GPS dog fence that best suits your pet’s needs and your lifestyle.

About PetSafe

PetSafe is a well-established brand in the pet care industry, recognized for its user-friendly products and commitment to pet safety. With over 25 years of experience, they have developed a wide range of products designed to enhance the lives of both pets and their owners. From their innovative GPS containment systems to their interactive toys and essential pet supplies, PetSafe prioritizes the well-being of animals and the bond they share with their humans.

One of the standout qualities of PetSafe is their dedication to creating products that are easy to use and understand. Their GPS collars, like the Guardian model, offer straightforward setup and intuitive app interfaces, making them accessible for both tech-savvy and less tech-inclined users. Moreover, their customer support team is readily available to assist with any questions or concerns, ensuring a positive experience for pet owners.

With a global presence and a commitment to giving back to the community, PetSafe has become a trusted partner for countless pet parents worldwide. Their dedication to innovation and animal welfare shines through in their product offerings and their ongoing efforts to promote responsible pet ownership.

About Halo

Halo is a relative newcomer to the GPS dog fence market, but it’s quickly gaining attention for its innovative approach to dog safety and training.  Founded by a team of tech experts and dog behaviorists, including renowned trainer Cesar Millan, Halo aims to create a more holistic solution that addresses both containment and behavior.

The Halo Collar utilizes advanced GPS technology and a smartphone app to create customizable virtual fences, eliminating the need for traditional physical barriers. This flexibility allows you to define safe zones wherever you go, whether it’s your backyard, a park, or a campsite. Halo also stands out with its personalized training programs, which are designed to help you build a stronger bond with your dog while establishing clear boundaries and expectations.

While Halo may be a newer brand, their commitment to innovation and dog well-being has already garnered a loyal following. Their unique approach to training, combined with advanced technology, offers a compelling alternative to traditional dog fences and training methods.

About SpotOn

SpotOn’s GPS dog fence system presents an intriguing option for dog owners seeking a reliable, accurate, and customizable solution for pet containment. 

One of SpotOn’s key differentiators is its True Location™ technology, which utilizes multiple satellite systems for unparalleled accuracy in tracking your dog’s location. This advanced GPS capability, combined with the ability to create customizable virtual fences of any shape and size, makes SpotOn a compelling option for those seeking a high level of precision and adaptability.

In addition to its technological potentia, SpotOn offers several notable features designed to enhance the user experience and ensure your dog’s safety. The system includes various correction options, such as tone, vibration, and static stimulation, allowing you to tailor the feedback to your dog’s temperament and training style. Furthermore, SpotOn’s Home Zones feature allows you to designate areas within your home where the collar won’t issue corrections, preventing any accidental triggers.

PetSafe’s GPS Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: What to Consider

As you weigh your options between PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn, several key factors will influence your decision. This ensures that you get the best fit for your furry friend and your lifestyle.

1. GPS Accuracy and Range

• PetSafe: PetSafe’s Guardian collar utilizes AccuGuard™ technology, a combination of GPS, motion detection, and AI, for enhanced accuracy and proactive boundary reinforcement. This allows for timely warnings before your dog reaches the boundary, minimizing the likelihood of escapes. The collar is designed for use in large areas, making it suitable for most residential properties, but like all GPS collars, it might face limitations in areas with limited satellite visibility.
• Halo: Halo boasts Precision GPS with a multi-satellite system for exceptional accuracy and minimal drift, ensuring reliable containment even in areas with weak cellular coverage. This is especially beneficial for those who frequent remote locations or require consistent performance in varying environments. However, some users have reported occasional issues with GPS connectivity, which can be a concern for those relying heavily on real-time tracking.

• SpotOn: SpotOn promotes accuracy with its True Location™ technology, utilizing multiple satellite systems for unparalleled precision. This is particularly advantageous for users with large properties or those living in areas with challenging terrain where consistent signal strength is crucial.

2. Geofencing and Virtual Fence Capabilities

• PetSafe: PetSafe offers a commendable level of flexibility with its customizable safe zones, allowing you to create up to 20 unique virtual fences of varying shapes and sizes. This feature is perfect for those who want to designate specific areas within their property or create temporary fences while traveling. However, the system might not be ideal for users who need a vast number of fences or highly intricate boundary shapes.

• Halo: Halo also provides customizable virtual fences, catering to different property layouts and outdoor activities. Its smart fence technology adds an extra layer of adaptability, automatically adjusting the boundary based on your dog’s location and behavior. However, the number of fences you can create might be limited compared to other systems.

• SpotOn: SpotOn enables you to create an unlimited number of virtual fences with any shape and size. This level of flexibility is a major advantage for larger properties or those with complex layouts, allowing you to tailor the boundaries precisely to your needs. However, this extensive customization might be more than what some users require.

3. Activity Tracking and Health Monitoring

• PetSafe: The PetSafe collar provides live tracking and precise GPS location, allowing you to see your dog’s real-time movement on a map. This helps prevent losing your dog and lets you relax while your furry friend explores safely.

• Halo: Halo goes beyond basic activity tracking by analyzing your dog’s behavior and providing insights into its well-being. It tracks activity levels and rest patterns and can even detect potential signs of stress or anxiety, giving you a deeper understanding of your dog’s needs. However, the depth of health monitoring might not match dedicated pet health trackers.

• SpotOn: SpotOn focuses primarily on containment and does not offer in-depth activity or health monitoring features. If these aspects are important to you, PetSafe or Halo might be more suitable options.

4. Training Features and Remote Commands

• PetSafe: PetSafe collars include tone and vibration correction options, providing a gentle way to reinforce boundaries and discourage your dog from straying.

• Halo: Halo’s personalized training programs, developed in collaboration with Cesar Millan, provide a structured and comprehensive approach to training. The app offers step-by-step guidance and allows for remote commands and feedback, making it a valuable tool for dog owners seeking professional training support. However, the training approach might not suit every dog or training style.

• SpotOn: SpotOn offers multiple correction options, including tone, vibration, and static stimulation, catering to different training approaches. While it may not have the same level of structured training programs as others, it provides the essential tools for basic obedience training and boundary reinforcement.

PetSafe’s GPS Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: Quality

When investing in a GPS dog fence, it’s essential to consider the quality and durability of the product, ensuring it can withstand your dog’s daily adventures and provide lasting value.

All three brands – PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn – offer GPS dog collars with varying degrees of quality and durability. PetSafe’s Guardian collar is known for its robust build and waterproof design, while Halo collars stand out for their sleek design and premium materials. SpotOn, with its rugged construction and water-resistant features, is also built to withstand the rigors of outdoor activities.

Ultimately, the best quality choice depends on your individual needs and priorities. If you have a particularly active dog or frequently engage in outdoor adventures, SpotOn’s rugged design might be the most appealing. However, if you prioritize a sleek and stylish collar that can withstand everyday wear and tear, PetSafe or Halo might be better suited to your needs.

PetSafe’s GPS Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: Price

Investing in a GPS dog fence is an investment in your pet’s safety and your peace of mind. However, the cost can vary significantly between brands and models, with additional factors like subscription fees to consider. Let’s break down the pricing structures for PetSafe, Halo, and SpotOn:

PetSafe

PetSafe offers a variety of collars to suit different budgets. While their wireless fences are available for under $200, these do not include GPS functionality. For GPS-enabled options, the basic models start at $300, with more advanced collars like the Guardian ranging from $400 to $500.

They typically require a subscription for features like real-time tracking and virtual fence management. However, they often offer discounts for annual plans, making them more affordable in the long run. The cost of the subscription can vary depending on the features you choose.

Halo

Halo collars are known for their premium features and technology, which is reflected in their pricing. The initial cost of a Halo collar can be upwards of $700, with additional costs for training accessories or multiple collars for multi-dog households.

Halo’s advanced features, including GPS tracking, personalized training programs, and real-time alerts, require a monthly or annual subscription fee. The cost of the subscription varies depending on the level of service you choose.

SpotOn

SpotOn’s technology and customization options come with a higher upfront cost compared to some other brands. The collar itself can range from $999 to $1,295, depending on the current promotions and discounts.

While SpotOn’s basic fence functionality does not require a subscription, you’ll need a monthly plan to access features like real-time tracking, escape notifications, and the ability to use the app to guide your dog back home. The subscription cost is relatively competitive compared to other brands.

PetSafe’s GPS Collar vs Halo vs. SpotOn: What Do Customers Think?

PetSafe

The true test of any product lies in the hands of its users. For the PetSafe Guardian® GPS + Tracking Dog Fence Collar, real-world feedback is overwhelmingly positive. Across various platforms, the collar consistently receives high ratings from satisfied pet owners.

On the official PetSafe website, the Guardian boasts an impressive average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars based on 54 reviews. This positive reception highlights the collar’s effectiveness, ease of use, and overall value for pet owners seeking a reliable and advanced GPS fence solution.

Retailers like Tractor Supply and Bass Pro Shop also echo this sentiment, with the Guardian receiving a 4.6 out of 5 star rating on both platforms. This consistent positive feedback across different channels reinforces the collar’s reputation for reliability and performance.

While the majority of reviews are positive, a few users have mentioned a slight learning curve with the app and the initial training process. However, most agree that the benefits of the collar outweigh any minor inconveniences.

Many pet owners appreciate the proactive nature of the AccuGuard™ technology, preventing their dogs from straying before they even reach the boundary. The intuitive My PetSafe® app is also frequently mentioned as a major plus, allowing for easy setup, monitoring, and management of the virtual fences. Also, user reviews often praise the Guardian’s accuracy, customizable virtual fences, and long battery life.

On the other hand, customers who have purchased the product from Chewy rated it slightly lower at 3.5 stars, with some users possibly encountering challenges or finding the system less suitable for their needs.

Overall, the PetSafe Guardian® GPS + Tracking Dog Fence Collar has garnered a strong reputation among pet owners, with consistently high ratings across various platforms. The positive feedback, particularly regarding its accuracy, flexibility, and user-friendly features, reinforces its position as a leading contender in the GPS dog fence market.

Halo

Halo Collar has garnered a reputation for its advanced technology and comprehensive approach to dog safety and training. On their own website, Halo boasts an impressive 4.7-star rating, highlighting a high level of customer satisfaction among those who have invested in the system. This positive feedback aligns with their emphasis on technology, training, and customer support.

While ratings on other platforms like Amazon and Trustpilot are slightly lower, averaging around 4 stars, they still reflect a generally positive sentiment towards the product. User reviews often praise Halo’s advanced features, such as precise GPS tracking, customizable virtual fences, and the effectiveness of the Cesar Millan-backed training programs. Many users find the real-time tracking and virtual fence features to be particularly valuable, providing peace of mind and flexibility for dog owners. Additionally, Halo’s customer support team is frequently commended for their responsiveness and helpfulness.

Some users have mentioned the higher price point and the subscription model as factors to consider. However, many find the investment worthwhile for the peace of mind and effective training it provides. While a few users have reported occasional issues with GPS connectivity or the app, these instances seem to be relatively infrequent compared to the overall positive feedback.

SpotOn

SpotOn has garnered a generally positive reception among users, with an average rating of 4.4 stars on their website. This feedback highlights satisfaction with its accuracy, customization features, and overall performance.

On Amazon, however, the rating is a bit lower at 3.8 stars. Some users mention experiencing challenges with setup or occasional inconsistencies in certain environments. However, the majority of reviews still acknowledge the collar’s strengths in accuracy and customization.

On Chewy, SpotOn receives a 4.5-star rating, indicating a high level of satisfaction among users who have purchased the collar from this platform.

Overall, the feedback for SpotOn is largely positive, with users praising its accuracy, customization options, and reliability in challenging terrains. While some users have experienced minor issues, the overall sentiment towards SpotOn remains favorable, making it a strong contender in the GPS dog fence market.

Promotions & Discounts

PetSafe

PetSafe understands that investing in your pet’s safety shouldn’t break the bank. That’s why they offer several enticing discounts and promotions to help you get the most out of your purchase of the Guardian collar.

• First-Year Subscription Savings. For those who plan to utilize the Guardian’s advanced features like real-time tracking and virtual fence management, PetSafe offers a generous discount on annual subscription plans. By signing up for a year, you can save 25% compared to paying monthly for the first year, making it a cost-effective option for long-term use.

• Multi-Dog Discount. Pet parents with multiple furry friends can rejoice with PetSafe’s multi-dog discount. Save 25% on each additional Guardian collar when you purchase two or more using the code 25OFF2 at checkout. This offer makes it easier to protect all your canine companions with the latest in GPS fence technology.
• Free Shipping. To sweeten the deal, PetSafe offers free shipping on all Guardian collar purchases. This means you can enjoy the convenience of having this cutting-edge technology delivered right to your doorstep without any additional shipping costs.

Halo

While Halo Collar’s advanced technology and comprehensive features come at a premium price point, the company offers several ways to make its system more accessible and budget-friendly for pet owners.

• Subscription Savings. Halo encourages users to opt for annual billing on their Pack Membership Plans, which include essential features like GPS tracking, virtual fences, and training programs. By choosing annual billing, you can save 15% compared to monthly payments, making it a more cost-effective option for long-term use. They even offer a 2-year plan that provides a 20% discount.

• Referral Program. Halo also offers a generous referral program that allows you to earn $50 in gift cards for each friend you refer who purchases and activates a Halo Collar. Additionally, if you refer two or more friends during their special bonus period, you can receive an extra $100 gift card.

SpotOn

While SpotOn’s cutting-edge technology and premium features do come with a higher initial investment, the company recognizes the importance of affordability for pet owners. To that end, they offer a few ways to save on their GPS dog fence system:

• Refer a Friend, Give $25, Get $25. SpotOn encourages its community of satisfied users to spread the word about their product through a generous referral program. By sharing a unique discount link with friends and family, you can gift them $25 off their purchase and earn $25 for yourself when they make a purchase. This win-win situation allows you to save on your own SpotOn investment while helping others discover the benefits of this innovative system.

• Limited-Time Offers and Discounts. SpotOn occasionally offers limited-time promotions and discounts on their website or through authorized retailers. These deals can range from percentage-based discounts to flat-rate savings on the collar or subscription plans. It’s worth checking their website regularly or signing up for their email list to stay informed about any current or upcoming offers.

Shipping & Returns

PetSafe

PetSafe prioritizes fast and convenient shipping for its US customers. Enjoy free standard shipping on orders exceeding $69 within the contiguous United States. 

Need it faster? Expedited shipping options are available for a fee. Subscription orders also come with free shipping. 

However, shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, and international locations may have limitations and additional costs. If you’re not completely satisfied with your purchase, PetSafe offers a 45-day return policy for a full refund of the product price.

Halo

Halo Collar ships to all 50 states in the US and most Canadian provinces, excluding Quebec and Yukon. While they don’t ship internationally at this time, orders within their coverage area typically ship within the timeframe indicated at checkout and include a tracking number for easy monitoring. 

Shipping costs $19.99 for complete collar kits and $9.99 for accessories.

SpotOn

All orders are manufactured, processed, and shipped from their facility in Manchester, New Hampshire, typically within two business days.

For US customers, this translates to a relatively quick delivery time, with most orders arriving within a few days of shipment. However, Canadian residents are responsible for all shipping costs, sales tax, customs duties, and brokerage fees associated with importing the product.

Also, it’s worth noting that they currently do not offer international shipping to other countries. This might be a limiting factor for potential customers outside of the US and Canada who are interested in the SpotOn system.

Who Will You Shop With?

With three compelling options to choose from, deciding on the perfect GPS dog fence for your furry friend ultimately comes down to your individual needs and priorities. Let’s recap the strengths of each brand to help you make an informed decision:

PetSafe

For many dog owners, PetSafe stands out as the most well-rounded and accessible option. With a wide range of models catering to various budgets and needs, PetSafe offers a solution for every pet parent. 

The Guardian collar, in particular, boasts innovative AccuGuard™ technology for enhanced accuracy and proactive boundary enforcement, ensuring your dog’s safety while giving them freedom to roam. The intuitive My PetSafe® app makes setup and management a breeze, and the availability of features like real-time tracking and customizable virtual fences further solidifies its appeal. 

PetSafe’s long-standing reputation for quality pet care products, coupled with positive customer feedback and accessible pricing, makes it a compelling choice for many dog owners seeking a reliable and effective GPS dog fence solution.

Halo

Halo’s strength lies in its comprehensive approach to dog safety and training. By combining advanced GPS technology with personalized training programs developed in collaboration with Cesar Millan, Halo offers a unique solution that not only contains your dog but also helps them learn and develop good behaviors. 

The real-time tracking and virtual fence features provide added peace of mind, and the 24/7 customer support ensures that you have assistance whenever you need it. However, the higher price point and subscription requirement may be a deterrent for some budget-conscious consumers.

SpotOn

SpotOn’s claim to fame is its unmatched accuracy and customization options. With its True Location™ technology and the ability to create unlimited virtual fences of any shape and size, SpotOn is an attractive choice for those with large properties or complex layouts. However, the higher initial investment and the potential learning curve involved in setting up the system might not be ideal for everyone.

Ultimately, the best GPS dog fence for you depends on your individual needs, preferences, and budget. 

If you’re looking for a reliable, user-friendly, and affordable solution with advanced features that cater to a wide range of needs, PetSafe emerges as a strong contender in the market. While Halo and SpotOn offer unique advantages, PetSafe’s combination of technology, affordability, and ease of use makes it a practical and appealing choice for many dog owners seeking to protect and enhance the lives of their furry companions.

---

Check out other related articles that you might also like:

Ollie Dog Food Review

SpotOn GPS Fence Review

Sundays Dog Food Review

Pet Plate Dog Food Review