Caraway vs Greenpan Review

About Caraway 

What’s the sense of trying to cook healthily when the non-stick pan you’re using is leaching toxic chemicals into your food? Both Caraway and Greenpan were created to clean up the cooking process, eliminating the PTFE emitted by Teflon by choosing ceramic.

Caraway, founded in 2018 by Jordan Nathan, is a small company of 10 employees situated in NYC. Offering a range of cookware, bakeware, and linens in gorgeous, modern colors, the brand designs its products in-house but has them made in factories in China and India.

About Greenpan

Greenpan exudes a classic, professional aesthetic in its wide variety of cookware, bakeware, electric appliances, and tools. Created in Belgium in 2007 and owned by The Cookware Company, it was the first to launch non-stick PTFE-free cookware to the world.

Headquartered in Ghent, Flemish Region, Greenpan has its own manufacturing facility in Jiangmen, China, but creates all of its designs in Belgium.

Ready to find out more? It’s all coming up in this Caraway vs Greenpan review.

Ahead, we’ll sizzle up a mix of juicy details about a selection of the brand’s popular products, whip through comparisons of each one’s quality, value, and policies, as well as provide a healthy serving of customer feedback. Before we jump in though, we’ve rounded up a short list of things to keep an eye out for as you browse.

What to Consider

Product Range

While browsing both of the brands, you may notice that one has a wider selection than the other, or that some sets include pieces (storage, pan protectors, etc.) that the other doesn’t. If you’re looking for products that fall outside of the ones included in this Caraway vs Greenpan review, then keep that in mind when making your final decision.

Target Audience

Even cookware is designed with an audience in mind. Usually, you can tell by the way it looks and the way it’s made, so it may be a good idea to pay attention to who each kind of product is aimed for. Professional cook? Omelet aficionado? Each piece is designed to cater to specific types of people.

Design and Durability

Maybe you care about looks more than performance. Or perhaps you want something you can throw around your kitchen and not have to worry about. We all cook and live differently, so when choosing your preferred set or piece of cookware, take a good look at how each product is made and what it’s made from.

Sustainability Efforts

We’re dealing with cookware here, but since both of these brands aim at providing a healthier cooking experience for their customers, it only makes sense that they strive to help make the world better too. Consider the sustainability practices of each one if that’s something that may sway your decision.

Extras

Whether you’re a seasoned chef or a newbie in the kitchen, it’s ideal to have resources at your fingertips. Both of these brands provide explicit details about the best way to use their cookware. But you may be looking for one that inspires you with recipes and cooking tips. Keep an eye out.

Accessibility

If you’re not the online shopping type, you may be looking for a brand that you can find at a store in your neighborhood. If so, you’ll want to pick a brand that’s easily accessible at one you normally visit or one that’s easy to get to. Keep that in mind as you browse.

In addition to where you can actually get it from, though we know this goes without saying, really look at the price, but more so, the value to determine if a particular set matches your needs.

The next section of this Caraway vs Greenpan review will walk you through a few of the brands’ popular sets and pans, comparing them side-by-side to help you see what makes each one unique. We’ve also included a concise pros and cons list for both companies for easy reference. Let’s get this thing cooking.

Caraway Cookware Set vs Greenpan Valencia Pro Ceramic Nonstick 11-Piece Cookware Set Review

Looking to update your cookware? Choosing a cohesive cooking set is a great way to set a high standard for your meals. It ensures you won’t have just one favorite pan in your cupboard of many that you use for literally everything (we speak from experience).

We’ll be checking out the Caraway Cookware Set first, a kit that comes complete with a range of pots, pans, and three lids, along with a handy magnetic storage system to keep it all in. Here’s the fine print:

• Fry Pan 10.5”
• Sauce Pan 3 qt
• Sauté Pan 4.5 qt
• Dutch Oven 6.5 qt
• Storage

Free from chemicals and affixed with stainless steel handles, this set is oven-safe up to 550°F and cooks up a range of meals from fried chicken to eggs to soup. Available in a range of dusty, modern colors, you can grab this set for $395, a value of $495 if you were to buy all the pieces individually.

Caraway Cookware Set:

• Well-rounded set
• Oven safe up to 550°F
• Non-toxic
• Comes with storage

The Valencia Pro Ceramic Nonstick 11-Piece Cookware Set is one of Greenpan’s non-stick ceramic collections, offering strong, durable pots and pans that are scratch-resistant. The shiny black set includes 11 diamond-reinforced pots, pans, lids, and pan protectors for all of your cooking adventures.

You’ll get three Fry Pans (8”, 9.5”, and 11”), three Saucepans (2 qt [6.3”], 3 qt [8”], 3, qt [9.5”]), one 5 qt Stockpot, and three Pan Protectors for $499.

Valencia Pro Ceramic Nonstick 11-Piece Cookware Set: 

• Magneto base doesn’t warp
• Non-toxic
• Inclusive set
• Comes with pan protectors

The Greenpan Valencia Pro Ceramic Nonstick 11-Piece Cookware Set comes with more pieces, so it may be a more appealing option for those who cook many different things. It’s offered in black only though, so if you’re looking for a pop of color, the Caraway Cookware Set may be more of a draw.

In the end, both sets are made of ceramic, are non-stick, and are oven-safe. We love that Caraway’s comes with storage, but also see how pan protectors would come in handy.

Caraway The Bakeware Set vs Greenpan Ceramic Nonstick 4-Piece Bakeware Set Review

This Caraway vs Greenpan review will now shift our focus to some crafty bakeware. 

Say goodbye to the annoying clanging and disorganization of your baking gear. Caraway The Bakeware Set comes with five pieces including a storage system to keep everything nice and tidy. You’ll get:

• Two Baking Sheets: 18”x13” & 10”x15”
• 12-cup Muffin Pan
• 9”x13” Rectangle Pan & 9” Square Pan

Choose from five trendy colors for bakeware so attractive you’ll want to keep it on your counter. Grab the set for $245 (normally $265). It’s also available in an eleven-piece set, too, if you’d rather something bigger.

Caraway The Bakeware Set: 

• Oven-safe up to 550°F
• Comes with storage solution
• Aluminum core with ceramic coating
• Available in pretty colors

There’s nothing worse than baking something only for it to stick to the pan. The Greenpan Ceramic Nonstick 4-Piece Bakeware Set includes all of the baking basics. With a 6-Cup Muffin Pan, Rectangular Cake Pan, Cookie Sheet, and Cooling Rack, you’ll be whipping up an assortment of your favorites without worry.

It comes in a pretty Tiffany’s turquoise for that Instagram-worthy home-baked photo. Get it for $19 (from $36).

Greenpan Ceramic Nonstick 4-Piece Bakeware Set: 

• Heats evenly
• Made from heavy-duty steel with reinforced rims
• Non-toxic
• Pretty color
• Oven safe up to 450°F
• Affordable

Greenpan’s set is smaller and it costs a lot less too. Low prices are amazing, but it makes us wonder if that lower price comes with less sturdy construction. According to the information, the pans look to be durable, but there’s something so satisfying about Caraway’s aesthetic.

Both baking sets will probably perform similarly, so aside from price, your decision may come down to how large of a pan you wish to have, as well as if you prefer to have included storage.

Caraway Fry Pan vs Greenpan Lima Ceramic Nonstick 8” Fry Pan Review

Fry Pans are such a versatile piece of cookware. Taking care of simple, quick meals from pancakes to sautéed green beans, this type of pan is a must for any household.

The Caraway Fry Pan gives you 10.5” of space to cook up all of your faves. Coated in ceramic with an aluminum core, this pan provides even heat dispersion. It comes in the brand’s signature six soothing colors, weighs a sturdy 2.8 lbs, and has an easy-grip stainless steel handle.

Safe in the oven up to 550°F, change the way you cook, clean, and eat with this easy-to-clean pan for $95.

Caraway Fry Pan:

• Non-toxic
• Heats evenly
• Oven-safe up to 550°F
• 1-year warranty

The Greenpan we’ll be checking out here is from the brand’s Lima Collection. Measuring 8” and made from ceramic, traditionally sticky meals like scrambled eggs slide off with ease without the need for scraping.

Made from Thermolon with an anodized build, the Greenpan Lima Ceramic Nonstick 8” Fry Pan resists scratches and is made to last. Grab the stainless steel handle and pop this sturdy beauty in the oven, it’s safe up to 600°F—but make sure you hand wash it only. Along with a lifetime warranty, you can get this pan for $18 right now, normally, it’s $35.

Greenpan Lima Ceramic Nonstick 8” Fry Pan: 

• Non-toxic
• Heats evenly
• Oven-safe up to 600°F
• Wipes clean easily
• Lifetime warranty

Caraway’s pan is slightly larger, but it’s also more expensive. The prices of these two pans may be what sways you towards one rather than the other, as they’re pretty matched in construction and in terms of what they can do.

Caraway vs Greenpan: Quality

Caraway Cookware is designed in New York but made in China and India. The brand has said that the factories it uses have strict ethical, SMETA, BSCI, and Fair Trade standards.

Made with an aluminum core with non-stick coating, its cookware has been manufactured with a mineral-based coating and none of the toxic stuff you’ll find with other non-stick pans. Shipped in recycled cardboard and no plastic, the brand is pushing for sustainability in all areas possible.

As for Greenpan, its non-stick, forged-base pans are made from Thermolon, a sand-derived ceramic that won’t leach chemicals into your food. With over 150 patents for its products, they’re designed to withstand tarnishing and have a copper-reinforced ferromagnetic layer on the bottom to prevent warping, as well as recycled aluminum.

Greenpan products are designed in Belgium and made just outside of Hong Kong, China in the brand’s own facility. Sources have said you can expect American standards with its cookware though. The factory is ISO-certified, audited four times a year, and does not use child labor.

Looking at both of these pans, we’ve learned that they’re each very durable and are made incredibly well. There seems to be a bit more complexity in Greenpan’s manufacturing process, and we also like the fact that the brand has its own factory in which they may be able to oversee tighter production.

With that said, both brands’ factories have great certifications and use high-quality materials. They’re pretty well matched in this area.

Caraway vs Greenpan: Price & Value

You may have noticed in the product comparison section of this Caraway vs Greenpan review that one is less expensive than the other. While it’s important to look at the price, sometimes, items with higher costs also have a higher value. Here, we’ll take a close look at what you’re getting from each and how that translates into value.

Since Caraway is known for its Cookware Set $395 (from $495), that’s what we’ll be looking into first. It bundles together four of its best-selling pots and pans, three lids, and one storage rack for a total of eight pieces. When we break down the average price per piece, it equals out to about $49.

Customers say that even though they love the quality of the pots, the storage rack is what makes this set so valuable, allowing them easy access. Additionally, another point of value is about how Caraway Cookware looks. Folks that get more enjoyment out of their pots and pans (aesthetically or otherwise) believe it has a higher value.

In general, customer feedback about Caraway Cookware quality is highly positive. Mentions of resilience, aluminized steel handles, and the pans’ non-toxic nature give them value as well.

Dishwasher safe, easy to clean, and the ability to be thrown in the oven, from what we’ve read, this brand looks to be convenient, attractive, and long-lasting.

And how does Greenpan stack up? We looked into its Cookware Set $499 for a matched comparison. The set includes seven pots and pans, three lids, and three pan protectors, or eleven pieces total with an average price of $45 per piece.

The Cookware Set’s review section shows high scores for quality across comments, with mentions of pans that cook quickly. Customers say they enjoy the look of Greenpan cookware, but we will admit we didn’t see it as often as we did for Caraway.

You’ll get the same non-toxic guarantee between brands though, but Greenpan is made from recycled aluminum (hence the word “Green”). With a limited lifetime warranty, this brand beats out Caraway’s 1-year term.

Which set is of a higher value? Well, when you break down the price per piece, Caraway and Greenpan both have similar costs, though, you’re getting a larger set with the latter. But then again, maybe pan protectors aren’t a big deal to you and you’d rather have something pretty on your countertop.

When it comes to the worth of a product, it’s important to keep in mind that often, value is in the eye of the beholder. Sally may have dreamed of dusty blue cookware her whole life and sees it as having greater worth, while Danny wants more tools to use for cooking.

Caraway vs Greenpan: What do Customers Think?  

Feedback is a critical part of shopping online. It’s easy to get swept away by beautiful images of dusty rose or sleek black cookware, but it’s the comments section that you’ll really want to pay attention to in order to find out how much you’re going to love your new set.

Combing through comments and review websites can be overwhelming and tedious—which is why we do it for you. In this section of our Caraway vs Greenpan review, you’ll find a collection of ratings and feedback from across the web.

Caraway’s website shows one overarching score for its cookware (sets and individual pans)—4.8/5 stars from 21,210 shoppers. That’s a pretty hefty score, and to see if it holds up, we headed off of the brand’s website to check in on quality and durability. Here’s what we found:

• The Spruce Eats: Cookware Set: 5/5 stars
• Chapters Indigo: Cookware Set: 4.8/5 stars from 13,281 reviews
• Bed, Bath & Beyond: Cookware Set: 4.8/5 stars from 13,142 reviews

It definitely looks like the score checks out. With high ratings across the web, we were interested in finding out what it is about the brand’s cookware that customers love so much. Common feedback includes:

• Appreciation for easy cleanup and that it’s dishwasher safe
• Handles are positioned well & easy to hold
• People love the magnetic organizational rack
• Absolutely no food sticking
• Love the luxury look
• Steady & even heat distribution

Though the Caraway Cookware Set has an overwhelmingly positive response, we did find a few comments that mentioned issues with staining on the outside and the general restrictions about how to properly use the pots and pans.

Though this doesn’t affect the cooking quality, it is an important point to mention, so just know there is a special way you’ll need to treat your new cookware—and this goes for Greenpan as well. Let’s check out what kind of feedback the competitor has:

We headed to the brand’s website first and recorded ratings for a few different products. You’ll find those below:

• Lima Fry Pan: 4.8/5 stars from 40 reviews
• Valencia Cookware Set: 4.4/5 stars from 80 reviews
• Valencia Sauce Pan: 5/5 stars from 5 reviews

Another set of high scores, we wandered off the brand’s website to find out more. Here’s a summary of what we saw:

• The Spruce Eats: Lima Cookware Set: 3.2/5 stars 
• Amazon: Lima Cookware Set: 4.6/5 stars from 1,023 reviews
• Bed, Bath & Beyond: Canterbury Set: 4.7/5 stars from 14 reviews

So what did folks like most about the cookware? We dove into the comments section of each source to check.

• Very heat-responsive—heats up quickly, cools quickly
• Great quality, durable
• Easy to clean
• Makes a difference in food taste and result

According to feedback for both brands, there may be a bit of a learning curve when it comes to using ceramic nonstick pans.

If you’re used to treating your cheaper pan any old way, it’s important to read the instructions and follow them to a T if you want to get the most out of your new ceramic cookware.

Both brands seem to have similar feedback, but we did notice that people tend to gravitate towards Caraway for the way its pans look. Just because they may look more trendy doesn’t mean they cook better though—the comments for durability and cooking results appear to be similar to Greenpan.

As you can see, scores for Caraway are higher across the board, but Greenpan does offer more variety, whereas its competitor has just one style of cookware.

Caraway vs Greenpan: Promotions & Discounts

Why buy something for full price when you can get a discount? This section of our Caraway vs Greenpan review will be dedicated to finding you every single last deal each of these companies has to offer.

Depending on the results, you may find yourself leaning towards one rather than the other, so let’s just get right to it.

Caraway

• Holds annual sales (for example, Black Friday promotion offered 20% off)
• Free shipping and returns on orders over $90
• Cookware Set value of $495 sold for $395
• 60-day trial

Greenpan

• Sale section
• Has annual promotions (for example, Black Friday promotion offered up to 40% off)
• Free gift with purchase
• Free shipping on all orders
• Refer a friend to get 25% off

Greenpan looks to have more deals, and who doesn’t love a free gift? But we also appreciate that both brands offer free shipping and hold yearly promotions like their Black Friday sale.

If you’re reading this Caraway vs Greenpan review when it’s not November, the presence of this sale is still important as it means the brand will most likely offer other promotions throughout the year. Sign up for each company’s mailing list to stay informed.

So, what will it be? Free shipping and returns, a trial, and annual sales? Or a year-round sale section, free gifts, and discounts for friend referrals?

Caraway vs Greenpan: Shipping & Returns

You’re dreaming of a brand new cookware set, maybe you’ve even started piling up your virtual cart. But here’s where you really need to pay attention, the last thing you want is for your happy visions of flipping pancakes to get ruined by waiting a lifetime for shipping.

Not everyone looks at the shipping and returns policies when shopping online, but receiving your products is kind of detrimental to cooking with them, wouldn’t you say?

In this section of our Caraway vs Greenpan review, we’ll lay out both brands’ shipping policies, as well as how returns work—just in case the need arises. We’ll start with Caraway.

Caraway:

Shipping

• Ships to all 50 states
• Standard shipping is free on orders over $90 for the 48 contiguous states, 2-5 business days
• Express shipping TBD for select items & Alaska and Hawaii, 3-7 business days
• Available through goop.com for those who live in Canada, the UK, and the EU, as well as Bed, Bath & Beyond, Crate & Barrel & more

Returns

• 60-day trial
• Returns are free
• May require a 15% restocking and repacking fee if your items are sent back in poorly packaged condition
• 1-year warranty

Greenpan:

Shipping

• Free standard shipping for 48 continental US, 5-8 business days
• Processing takes 1-5 business days
• Shipping to Hawaii, Alaska, and Puerto Rico is $30
• For those outside of the US, you can find Greenpan on Amazon, Bed, Bath & Beyond, Williams Sonoma & more

Returns

• 60-day refund policy on unused items with their original packaging
• Return shipping is your responsibility 
• If your pan has a defect, Greenpan will replace it
• 2-year warranty

Since both brands offer free shipping to the continental US and are available at a number of stores outside of America, the biggest difference we found was in the returns policies. We appreciate brands that offer free trials, and when it comes to cookware, that’s really saying something about the pans themselves.

Caraway’s free trial takes the pressure off of making a big purchase like its Cookware Set and makes buying from them a little more appealing. With that said, Greenpan offers a longer warranty that covers defects. Both with attractive deals, your pick comes down to what makes you feel more secure when purchasing.

Who Will You Shop With?

During this Caraway vs Greenpan review, we’ve come to understand that these brands are quite different in looks and price, but they seem to be on par in terms of performance and the chemicals they leave out.

Both cookware lines were created to eliminate toxic chemicals from the cooking process, and if you’re looking for a simple, sturdy, and inexpensive product, we think one stands out over the other. With that said, if a modern look and storage system are important to you, then we know which one may be more attractive.

In the end, cooking needs vary, and we can see the major appeals of both Caraway and Greenpan. To us, they’re both amazing lines, it’s just a matter of budget and preference.

---

Check out some other brand comparisons you might enjoy:

Ooni vs Gozney Review

YETI vs Hydro Flask Review

Monos vs Rimowa Review

Ipsy vs Birchbox Review