Jack Erwin vs Meermin Shoes Review

Jack Erwin vs Meermin: Style Showdown

Jack Erwin’s mission is to make shoes that fit everyday needs and surpass expectations. While Jack Erwin shoes are made for city life and daily routines, with their luxe design and materials, they stand out. Meermin flattens the barrier to high-quality shoes with excellent prices. Meermin makes shoes with the finest materials with equal elegance and durability. 

The following comparative Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review will examine key elements of the brand and its products to assist you in making an informed purchase decision.  

Jack Erwin vs Meermin Boots

Jack Erwin Chelsea Boot

We’ll dive into this Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review and begin with the popular Chelsea boot. The Men’s Chelsea Boot by Jack Erwin creates an impeccable balance between elegance and pragmatism. The Chelsea boot is offered in Rocco and Ollie styles, with options including full grain leather and suede. The Chelsea boot, with Jack Erwin’s CITY sole, is made for covering ground on city streets.

Perfect for exploring and staying active while looking put together and polished, the Chelsea Boot is made with weatherized leather, so that you don’t have to slow down or shy away from what the day holds. Nothing will slow you down in this boot; it is easy to pull on. Durable and long-lasting, the Chelsea becomes an integral part of your closet and identity. 

You can wear the Jack Erwin Women’s Chelsea Boot in three styles: the Robie, the Thea and the Quinn. Colours range from tan Nappa, black suede, tan suede, black Nappa leather, tan polished leather, black polished leather with a black outsole and polished brown leather. This classic boot has an edge of feminine elegance with a low heel. You can slip them on easily, and they’re highly walkable for the woman who enjoys clocking miles and getting it all in. 

The almond-shaped toe is defined but subtle, and the boots are handcrafted in Portugal made of fine and quality Italian Nappa leather or suede. Just like the men’s boot, the women’s Chelsea has a micro-foam insole, that keeps you in motion without any hold-back or interruption. The sturdy leather-sole will make you feel in-charge. 

Meermin Chelsea Boot

In this part of the Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, we’ll talk about Meermin’s handsome Chelsea boots. They have a whole-cut pattern, creating an elegant line with no side seams. The Chelsea is made of the finest hides and has a double rubber sole, which can quickly be resolved to ensure durability.

The ankle opening is slimmer, like the boot. This contributes to the classy style of the shoe, lending to a tapered look. Fabric tabs in the front and back make it easy to stay on-the-go. Meermin makes these boots to fit you, your lifestyle and any occasion. The boot is Goodyear welted to last. Built for elegance and convenience, the rubber sole with added traction will give you confidence in all of your pursuits.

Jack Erwin Chukka Boot

The Men’s Chukka Boot from Jack Erwin is made to match Jack Erwin’s mantra: life happens on the go. Versatile and comfortable with a rubber outsole, the boot has traction to match the conditions of any city street. At the same time, it is detailed in design with three eyelets and blade-shaped stitching at the laces. Handcrafted in Portugal, the padded foam insole makes walking enjoyable. 

Meermin Chukka Boot

We found in this Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, that the Meermin Men’s Chukka Boot enjoys a mixture of old-time elegance and hipster chic. The Chukka is a casual boot ideal for the fall and spring seasons. The symmetrical pattern will enhance the look of any pair of trousers or chinos. 

The Chukka for women from Meermin is timeless with a refined exterior and a comfortable interior that gets more comfortable with the mileage. The French full-grain leather or Italian suede is not only supple and beautiful but combined with a double rubber sole, the Chukka is a full year boot that is more and more likeable with wear. With its delicate design disguising durability, the Chukka will set you apart. 

Winner: Jack Erwin

In a Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review between two beautiful brands of boots – the winning brand is Jack Erwin with the Chelsea and Chukka boots.

While the Meermin Chukka has an artistic, refined and stylish look, the boot is restricted to the fall and winter seasons. The Meermin Chelsea is elegant but not as durable and city-savvy as the Jack Erwin boot. The Meermin Chukka is less durable and less capable of distance than the Chelsea, which is built for walking.

Jack Erwin vs Meermin Shoes

Jack Erwin Oxford

When it comes to men’s shoes in this Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, we must talk about the iconic oxford style. The Oxford is Jack Erwin’s version of the timeless brogue cap-toe oxford priced at $195– $235. The shoe has modern detailing with single punches on the cap toe. This refreshed look differs from the more standard broguing pattern.

Beautifully made from French and Italian tanneries, the full-grain calfskin is handcrafted in Portugal. The luxe shoes are composed of hand-stitched leather and supported with a stacked heel. Lined with a micro-foam insole, every gentleman will look handsome and feel supported in these beautiful shoes. 

Meermin Oxford

The Meermin’s Men’s Oxford is contemporary with its longer shape and soft squared toe box. The shoe is a dressy choice, made with the finest French Box-calf leather, with thick vegetable-tanned leather insoles. Created by talented artisans, the shoes are Goodyear welted. The shoes age well, looking more distinguished with wear. 

Jack Erwin Loafer

The Jack Erwin Driving Loafer is designed for a classic appearance and a feeling of comfort. The full rubber outsole and microfoam make the shoe a desirable asset to any demanding schedule. Handcrafted in Portugal and effortless to pull on and off, the shoes are built to last. 

Jack Erwin Women’s Loafer is a traditional cut with a round toe that fits with every season. The women’s loafer is handcrafted in Portugal from Nappa leather, giving it a pristine and classic look. Designed with daily needs in mind, its technical sole is sleeker and sturdier. While the shoe is simple, the stacked leather makes it an item that you can dress up.

Meermin Loafer

This Meermin loafer for men is an eye-catching model. With a round-toe shape and low instep, the loafer will wear in to be your most beloved shoe. Perfect for work or leisure, you can dress this loafer up or down. The leather soles make the loafers lasting, and the supple full-grain calf lining and thick vegetable-tanned leather give the shoe a luxurious interior.

The Meermin women’s loafer is ageless and timeless. Like the men’s loafer, the women’s model is made of quality full-grain calf leather and tanned leather, guaranteeing comfort and durability. The sleek shoe can be paired stylishly with any outfit while allowing you to move freely. 

A Tie Between Brands 

This one is a tie in our Jack Erwin vs. Meermin review. Meermin’s Loafer comes on top of Jack Erwin’s loafer. Featured in a wide range of styles for both men and women, the Loafer is a stylish everyday shoe that is adaptable to many styles and purposes. You can wear them with both casual and formal attire, and their polished, distinctive look sets them apart.

Jack Erwin’s Oxford, on the other hand, is strides ahead of Meermin’s model. Though Jack Erwin’s price is higher, it is adaptable to occasion and purpose. The Meermin shoe is modern, while Jack Erwin’s Oxford takes from both the past and the present, striking a natural balance. With a micro-foam insole, the Jack Erwin shoe will take you through your workdays comfortably, supporting your movement and helping you to achieve your goals. 

Quality

Jack Erwin makes their shoes for functional high performance. With that in mind, notable aesthetics are embedded in a foundation of quality construction. For Jack Erwin, however, aesthetics are a minimal component that enables the company to place emphasis on the build and design of the boots and shoes. 

Jack Erwin’s aim is that their shoes meet everyday standards and are a staple in any wardrobe. As a result, the shoes are hand-stitched using deliberately flexible, durable materials with weather-resistant soles. Made in Portugal, the shoes are made of refined materials including Italian Nappa calfskin, buttery nubuck and whole cut suede. 

Meermin’s main priority is quality materials. Meermin has strong, collaborative relationships with the top tanneries in France, Italy & Japan, which allows the company to access the highest grade materials and the best quality control. Meermin builds their boots to last, and their styles reflect a meticulously handcrafted approach that surpasses the limits of seasonal taste or short-lived affection. 

Meermin makes their shoes to carry on mile after mile, and they are Goodyear Welted to make this vision practicality. Finally, Meermin is a direct-to-consumer brand. They see through every part of the process, and there are no markups. 

Winner: Jack Erwin

If you pick one boot or shoe that you will love unconditionally through countless seasons, turns in weather and ambitious adventures back and forth across the city, it is the Jack Erwin shoe, and your choice is rooted in the quality of the shoe. 

In completing a Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, it is clear that Meermin constructs a beautiful shoe that stands out in style, taste and detail, but Jack Erwin puts their focus on long-lasting, durable shoes ahead of aesthetics. Additionally, like the Meermin, Jack Erwin is skillfully handcrafted and made from extraordinary materials. 

Customer Ratings 

When comparing customer satisfaction in this Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, customers reported that Jack Erwin shoes broke in quickly and were more comfortable compared to other shoes that they owned. Customers felt that Jack Erwin’s customer service was responsive, empathetic, courteous and fast-acting. Shoes held up through many challenging and adverse weather conditions; however, without regular care, they did show their age.

The purpose of the shoes was commonly described as ‘everyday shoes.’ Customers stated that the shoes were easy to resole and were inexpensive, especially relative to their quality. Customers would return for more products from Jack Erwin. 

Customers reported that customer service was unresponsive and poor. Customers expressed that the shipping process was frustrating and unsatisfactory. Others commented that the quality was exquisite, and the price was fair. Customers were satisfied with the craftsmanship, details, and comfort and found the shoes to be long lasting. 

Through analyzing our Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, Jack Erwin came out far ahead of Meermin in customer ratings. While there were some strong points to the commentary of Meermin customers, the customer service, shipping and UX commentary was far below standard. Jack Erwin had a compassionate customer service team, and their shoes met the mark on longevity and application to daily life. 

Winner: Jack Erwin

On the whole, Jack Erwin customers were satisfied with all facets of the product and experience. On the contrary, many Meermin customers were irritated and even furious at the treatment they received in the course of purchasing the product. This difference in the trust and commitment of customers to the brand was the biggest difference in the Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review.

Shipping & Returns 

Jack Erwin Shipping

• All standard orders are shipped free
• Jack Erwin ships orders via FedEx or SmartPost
• Orders should arrive within 7-10 business days of the shipping date
• Jack Erwin does not ship outside of the 48 contiguous states

Jack Erwin Returns

• Discounted products are final sale or eligible for store credit
• Full priced items may be accepted for return if the return is unused and is placed in the original box with all contents and packaging
• Additionally, the return must be sent back within 30 days
• No worn or damaged items are accepted
• Gift cards and expedited shipping charges are non-refundable
•  Allow 5-10 days for the return to Jack Erwin for inspection
• Allow another 3-5 days for the refund to be processed 

Meermin Shipping

• Meermin ships their products around the world
• The company strives to dispatch orders within 24-48 hours
• Meermin is not responsible for delays related to customs or clearance
• At the time that your order is shipped, you will receive an email confirmation
• The confirmation will include a tracking number and shipping details
• Register with Meermin to view your shipment and track its status 
• You can do so by selecting ‘My Account’ and ‘Orders’
• Meermin ships with UPS, FedEx & DHL depending on location

Meermin Returns

• Customers have 15 days to return the item
• For the return to be accepted, the item must be unworn or brand new; if you are trying on the shoes, do so on carpeted surfaces, as scratched soles will not be accepted
• For exchanged items, Meermin will ship at no incurred cost
• Refunds will take ten business days to process

A Tie Between Brands 

We compared the shipping and returns in our Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review and we found that while Jack Erwin ships standard orders for free, they do not ship outside of the 48 contiguous states. Meermin, on the other hand, ships internationally. Meermin allows 15 days for a return, while Jack Erwin offers a more generous 30 days. 

Jack Erwin’s shipping service is less advanced than Meermin’s international service. However, Jack Erwin provides a more accommodating service for returns. In this respect, the companies are comparable for shipping and returns and come out in a tie. 

Jack Erwin Prices vs Meermin Prices

	Jack Erwin Men’s	Meermin Men’s	Jack Erwin Women’s	Meermin Women’s
Chelsea Boot	$185-$195	$230	$225	$220
Chukka Boot	$165	$200-$420	N/A	$200-$420
Oxfords	$195-$235	N/A	$175	N/A
Loafers	$125-$145	$175-$350	$195	$165-$175

With the Chelsea Boot, the prices were comparable in our Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review for women’s boots. Jack Erwin Chelsea and Chukka boots cost less compared to Meermin. On the other hand, Jack Erwin’s Oxfords were considerably more expensive, while Meermin’s men’s loafers were the opposite.

For the most part, Jack Erwin comes at a lesser cost for good quality. Note that Meermin’s handcrafted shoes are made out of materials from the finest tanneries in the world and their fine style reflects this craftsmanship. 

We Choose: Jack Erwin

Jack Erwin vs. Meermin Review – Wins and Losses

	Jack Erwin	Meermin
The Boot	√
The Shoes	√	√
Quality	√
Customer Ratings	√
Shipping and Returns	√	√
Cost	√

To sum up this Jack Erwin vs Meermin shoes review, Jack Erwin was the preferred brand for 4/6 categories. Jack Erwin excels at creating quality in their shoes. This commitment to performance is what gives them a leading edge.  

When customers are loyal to a brand and have the desire to come back again and again, it is the most significant clue that the company is doing something right. Not only do customers think Jack Erwin shoes are excellent, but they genuinely feel supported by the customer service team. This kind of trusting relationship makes the purchase seamless, reliable and hassle-free.

The quality of Jack Erwin shoes is what makes them transitional to every season, occasion and weather that might be faced in one 24 hour rotation. They are elegant and fit into any wardrobe as a go-to. Customers can feel uninhibited throughout their days because they can go anywhere, boldly, stylishly and in comfort.

---

Next, read our in-depth reviews for Jack Erwin and Meermin.