Mystery Tackle Box Review

About Mystery Tackle Box

Thinking about hitting the lakes and ponds, but find your tackle box is empty? Don’t worry, the Mystery Tackle Box by Catch Co. can fill it up with everything you need to go fishing. 

As a monthly lure subscription service, the brand sends you a wide variety of lures and tackles for your fishing needs. You get a whole month’s worth of goodies with each delivery, and you can choose between different packages depending on what species you want to fish. 

The company boasts that their products are 40% off retail, bringing you high-quality products for a low price. 

If you’re a beginner, don’t worry! The brand also has expert how-to videos, magazines, and blog posts to get you ready before casting your fishing line. 

With 756k followers on Instagram and over 700k likes and follows on Facebook, the company is definitely popular. You can also find their happy customers posting about their successful catches. 

But do the boxes really deliver? This Mystery Tackle Box review will ‘tackle’ the details about the company, products, and customer comments to help you decide. 

Overview of Mystery Tackle Box

Ross Gordon has always loved fishing. In 2012, he founded Catch Co. and Mystery Tackle Box to help anglers find the newest fishing lures without having to do all the research themselves. With plans to deliver over 2.5 million boxes in 2021, it’s clear the company has no other plans besides growth. 

Before we jump into the products, let’s take a look at the general pros and cons of the brand. 

Pros

• Wide range of products within each tackle box to keep you busy 
• Different species-specific packages 
• Free shipping on all orders 
• You can pause or cancel your subscription at any time
• Beginner and expert-friendly 
• There is no deadline to place your order 

Cons

• Some products can ship to Canada but not all, you will need to check your individual product pages 
• Shipping to Canada takes up to three weeks for delivery 
• No returns or exchanges for monthly subscription or specialty boxes 
• You can’t add items or buy products individually (it’s called a ‘mystery’ tackle box for a reason)

When you visit their website, you can choose between buying a plan for yourself or sending one as a gift. There are three main types of packages and different species-specific options too, with plenty of room for choice. You can also decide the duration of your plan, but we will get more into this later on. 

How Does Mystery Tackle Box Work?

The subscription plan provides products from large and small manufacturers on a monthly basis. While you can’t add items or buy products individually, you can choose specific products, from lures to rods, through their affiliated brand, Karl’s Bait & Tackle. 

This Mystery Tackle Box review finds that the subscription is a really easy process. All you need to do is: 

1. Pick a plan: standard, pro, or elite
2. Choose the species you want to fish 
3. Choose your duration 
4. Receive your box with free shipping 

Each box contains a mix of lures and bait. This Mystery Tackle Box review will get into all the nitty gritty details about each plan to give you the best idea of what would suit your needs. 

This brand doesn’t carry a wide range of products other than their monthly subscription packages. If you want to buy individual items, you can check out Karl’s Bait & Tackle, also under Catch Co. Regardless, this Mystery Tackle Box review will take you through the plans you can choose. 

Mystery Tackle Box Regular Review 

If you’re looking to spice up your fishing routine or get started without fumbling in the fishing aisle, the brand has an assortment of options for you: regular, pro, and elite. 

At $17-$20 per month, the Regular pack is the most affordable and popular option, especially for beginners. When you sign up, you choose the species you want to fish specifically, for example, the Mystery Tackle Box trout would be best for trout. 

This pack has four main options: 

1. Bass: suited for largemouth, smallmouth, and spotted bass
2. Inshore Saltwater: suited for redfish, speckled trout, snook, and flounder 
3. Panfish and Trout: suited for crappie, perch, bluegill, and trout (rainbow, brown, brook, and cutthroat) 
4. Walleye and sauger 

Each box typically retails around $25 so you will be saving some money, but the main appeal is the varying range of items each time. 

You can choose between the one-time monthly, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month plans. Of course, the more months you buy, the more money you save. While you can cancel at any point, you will keep receiving the boxes until the end of your subscription period. 

Mystery Tackle Box Pro Review

If you know what you like, the Mystery Tackle Box Pro would be a better option for you. Ranging from $27-$30 per month, this box contains more intricate products, but some customers report that they aren’t all useful. If you want to try out new products, this box will be sure to bring you something fresh every month, especially for Mystery Tackle Box catfish. 

There are five species options: 

1. Bass: suited for largemouth, smallmouth, and spotted bass
2. Multi-species: including bass, panfish, and catfish 
3. Inshore Saltwater: suited for redfish, speckled trout, snook, and flounder 
4. Panfish and Trout: suited for crappie, perch, bluegill, and trout (rainbow, brown, brook, and cutthroat) 
5. Walleye and sauger 

Like the other box, you can decide between monthly, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month plans. Find one that suits your needs best! 

Mystery Tackle Box Elite Review

Last but not least, the Mystery Tackle Box Elite contains premium gear best reserved for those who know what they want and how to use different tackle and bait. Unfortunately, this option has the least choices: 

1. Bass: suited for largemouth, smallmouth, and spotted bass
2. Multi-species: including bass, panfish, and catfish 

But like the other two boxes, you can choose between monthly, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month plans, ranging between $37-$40 per month. 

Remember, all the boxes can be cancelled or upgraded at any time, but they will also auto-renew at the end of each period. 

How Much Is Mystery Tackle Box?

While we know the different types of boxes, this section will give you the lowdown on all the prices. 

Regular Box prices: 

• Monthly plan: $20 per month
• 3-month plan: $19 per month, saving $12 a year
• 6-month plan: $18 per month, saving $24 a year 
• 12-month plan: $17 per month, saving $36 a year

Pro Box prices: 

• Monthly plan: $30 per month
• 3-month plan: $29 per month, saving $12 a year
• 6-month plan: $28 per month, saving $24 a year
• 12-month plan: $27 per month, saving $36 a year

Elite Box prices: 

• Monthly plan: $40 per month
• 3-month plan: $39 per month, saving $12 a year
• 6-month plan: $38 per month, saving $24 a year
• 12-month plan: $37 per month, saving $36 a year

Mystery Tackle Box Reviews: What Do Customers Think?

Before giving our own verdict, this Mystery Tackle Box review took a look at customer reviews from across the web! With glowing testimonies from Youtubers and a 4.5 star rating from 7,168 comments on Trustpilot, it’s clear that customers are happy with their purchases. 

Customers enjoy the variety of the boxes and excellent customer service, a must for all subscription services.

Daniel Diaz wrote: They have the best customer service. I had a couple issues with the shipping because of the postal services and when I reached out I had a response very quickly and they did everything to keep me happy! Good prices as well!

Patrick agreed: “I love my MTB subscription. I get the opportunity to try techniques I wouldn’t unless I got my box every month. Reasonably priced and great customer service in my experience.”

Is Mystery Tackle Box Subscription Worth It?

Ultimately, this Mystery Tackle Box review finds that a subscription is worth it. If you are open to trying new things or you’ve never bought a tackle box before, this package is a low cost and hassle-free product. It saves you the trouble of figuring out what to get yourself, especially if you’re fishing for a specific species. 

Mystery Tackle Box Promotions & Discounts 

At the time of this review, there are no Mystery Tackle Box coupons. But if you sign up for their newsletter, you can get the latest news on promotions and discounts. If there is a new event, you’ll be the first to get the Mystery Tackle Box code. 

Sign Up For Mystery Tackle Box Subscription

It’s an easy and painless process to sign up for a subscription. All you need to do is: 

1. Pick the plan that would best suit you. If you’re a beginner, you should choose “regular”. 
2. Choose the type of fish from the drop down menu.
3. Choose the duration from the drop down menu. 

If you want to change anything about your subscription, you can easily make adjustments to your account at any time. 

FAQ

What comes in a Mystery Tackle Box? 

This Mystery Tackle Box review found each cardboard package includes products from reputable sources, brought to you in a more accessible format for you to test them out. You’ll also receive an information booklet outlining how to use each product and other fishing tips. 

Don’t worry, the company doesn’t throw you into the deep end and expect you to swim. They’ll help you every step of the way, and if you still don’t understand what you received, you can easily contact their customer service. 

Can you order just one Mystery Tackle Box? 

Yes! If you buy the monthly option and cancel before your next auto-renewal, you can receive one box. Another option is the line of Specialty Boxes from Karl’s Bait & Tackle. At different price points and themes, their limited inventory is another option for individuals who want to try something new without committing to a subscription plan. 

How do I change my Mystery Tackle Box? 

This is a really easy process! If you find that you want to change your box type to another species, just follow these steps: 

• Sign in to your account
• Click the “Switch” button beside your subscription dashboard
• Select the desired species
• Click “Change Species”
• Return to your subscription dashboard and see your new preferred box type confirmed at the top

As long as you submit all changes before the last day of the month, your changes should be reflected in your next box. If you have any other questions, you can readily contact their customer service. 

Who is Mystery Tackle Box for? 

This Mystery Tackle Box review finds the subscription boxes suit anyone—from beginner to pro—who wants to try new tackles for their next fishing trip. But if you’ve never touched a fishing rod before, you might have a hard time figuring out how to use the various products, though their information guide should be clear enough. 

On the other hand, experts might find the boxes to be a waste if they don’t need everything the box has to offer. Even worse, there might be repeats in your own inventory. This is why Karl’s Bait & Tackle exists—you can find what you need there without locking yourself into a monthly subscription and potentially unwanted items. 

What is Mystery Tackle Box’s Shipping Policy?

For all US locations, free shipping is available, where delivery would take up to 7 business days to arrive by USPS. You can also choose 2-day expedited shipping for $10 if you’re in a hurry, but this is not available for all orders. 

As of April 2021, free shipping to Canada and Mexico is also available on select products, and this would take between 2-3 weeks for delivery. 

What is Mystery Tackle Box’s Return Policy?

There are no returns or exchanges on the monthly subscription boxes. 

How do I cancel my Mystery Tackle Box subscription?

If you just want to change your box type, you just need to: 

1. Log into your account. 
2. Under the main dashboard, click on the “Switch” button beside your current species and choose the option you want from what’s available. 

If you want to stop your subscription: 

1. Log into your account. 
2. Scroll to the bottom of your active subscriptions and select to ‘pause’ your subscription for however long you want.
3. Or you can choose to stop it completely. 

Or, this Mystery Tackle Box review found that you can also cancel your subscription through email. You can do one of these options: 

1. Contact their support email [email protected] about your cancellation request. 
2. Send your email through the online support form. 

How to Contact Mystery Tackle Box

Since this brand and Karl’s Bait & Tackle are under the same parent company, this Mystery Tackle Box review found you can contact both companies the same way. 

The support team is available from Monday to Sunday, 9:00 am to 7:00 pm CST. 

• Online request form
• Email: [email protected]
• Live Chat
• Phone: 844-682-5833

You can give them a call from Monday to Friday between 9 am to 5 pm CST. 

---

Check out some other top men’s subscriptions in our curated list, Best Subscription Boxes for Men.